That's Lucy center. I have a different version of this photo with the whole class. Pauline Lopus is next to her in that one.
I'll dig up that one I have tonight. I think this is to be a 9th grade photo.
Just re-reading THIS one, Luvs, and if you have one with Pauline Lopus, she NEVER went to Jamestown H.S., with Lucille; Pauline would have been in high school at Celoron, prior to centralization to Southwestern in mid-50's; i.e. if your photo is 9th grade, the one showing above is way-beyond 9th grade; don't see Lucille there either, although it claims to be. In any event, IF it's Lucille, Pauline is NOT in photo, unless it's an earlier year.
I believe when Lucille came back to Jamestown, moving into apartment w/her mom, in Jamestown, tried to finish high school, which she had failed to graduate, was trying to graduate; and it's my understanding she NEVER graduated; but, went back to what is now historically-known as her big chance in Hollywood.